David Drennan

Proposed Title

Beyond Flexibility in Fatwas: Engaging Power, Progress, and Modernity in Islamic Thought


Standard discussion of maqasid al-shari‘a in both English and Arabic jump from the texts of al-Shatibi (d. 1388) to their revival by Muhammad ‘Abduh (d. 1905) at the turn of the twentieth century, then to the works of Ibn ‘Ashur (d. 1973). Little mention is made of the five-hundred-year gap between Shatibi and his modern interlocutors. The present research shows that, contrary to this understanding, Maliki scholars were a) aware of Shatibi and his works on maqasid; b) there is evidence his work was transmitted via his students and directly; and c) Mauritanian scholars abridged and commented on Shatibi’s works at the turn of the twentieth century, parallel to the revival efforts of ‘Abduh, but were not connected to this movement.

My research focuses on analysing the legal works of two prominent Mauritanian jurists at the turn of the twentieth century in their social and intellectual contexts. These are Ma’ al-‘Aynayn al-Qalqami (d. 1910), who was a noted resistance leader, Sufi, and scholar par excellence in his time, and Muhammad Yahya al-Walati (d. 1912), given the title ‘Al-Faqih’  (‘The Jurist’) within his lifetime due to his erudition in Islamic legal theory (usul al-fiqh) and juristic principles (qawa‘id).

Why I chose Charles Sturt

I have known of the Centre for Islamic Studies and Civilisation since its inception, through their tireless community work and outreach. I have known a number of staff members professionally for many years, so when the opportunity to undertake my PhD opened up, I decided to commence it in the supportive and collegial environment at the Centre.

Engagement and memberships

  • Australian Association of Islamic and Muslim Studies [AAIMS]
  • Australian Association for the Study of Religions [AASR]
  • International Society for Islamic Legal Studies [ISILS]


Current candidate profiles